The last French Revolution

Every uprising, revolt or revolution in France draws inspiration from the previous one, so technically all can be traced back to the Jacquerie, a revolt by French peasants in the early summer of 1358, which predated the English Peasants’ Revolt, of 1381 by 23 years. But I’m sure this wasn’t the first, the Parisii must have revolted against their Lutècian Roman overlords, Asterix the Gaul isn’t totally fiction. So French revolutions must be older than France itself.

It is therefore unwise to try to pinpoint a trigger for the 1968 uprising, but its inevitability was ensured by the events of 17 October 1961, when up to 300 Algerian demonstrators were massacred by French National Police and their bodies thrown into the Seine on the orders of the head of the Parisian police, Maurice Papon. The event was downplayed in the media and no one was prosecuted, resulting in the Parisian police becoming a criminal gang, unaccountable and above the law. A further massacre took place on 8 February 1962, at Charonne métro station when nine communist members of the CGT trade union were murdered by police, again directed by Maurice Papon, who by this time was no better than Al Capone, the gangster who ran Chicago in the 1930s. It is perhaps surprising that it took another six years for the uprising to begin and that it didn’t start in the liberal / socialist Latin Quarter of Paris.

pont-st-michel

Pont Saint-Michel, 75006 Paris, the morning after the killings

The 1968 uprisings actually started in Warsaw, Poland. (The election of reformist Alexander Dubček as First Secretary of the Communist Party of Czechoslovakia on 5 January 1968, hardly counts as an uprising!) On the 8 March, a crowd of over a thousand demonstrating students at Warsaw University was violently attacked by a state organised “worker squad” (plainclothes police) as well as police in uniform. A demonstration the next day at the Warsaw Polytechnic ended in further police violence and arrests. Within a few days protests spread across Poland. The crisis resulted in the suppression of student strikes by security forces in all major academic centres across the country and the suppression of the Polish dissident movement. It was followed by mass Jewish emigration due to an anti-Semitic campaign waged by the minister of internal affairs.

studentenwarschau1968

Students trying to flee from armed militia in Krakowskie Przedmiezcie, Warsaw

Yet Paris remains the iconic image associated with that year. The Paris uprising was not inspired by the events in Warsaw but was entirely due to home-grown grievances. France was very different in 1968 – married women were not allowed to open bank accounts without written permission from their husbands, and students were not allowed to entertain the opposite sex in their rooms. Even so, it did not start on the left bank, and it was not even started by a Frenchman! The following timeline is a brief summary of the extraordinary events of Paris ‘68:

22 March

Sociology students at Nanterre University in a grim north western suburb of Paris, led by a 22 year old German, Daniel Cohn-Bendit, occupied the administration block in a protest  against political, spiritual and sexual oppression. The authorities called the police, who surrounded the university. After publication of their demands, the students left without trouble.

cohn-bendit

Daniel Cohn-Bendit, 1968

2 May

Following continued unrest, Nanterre University was shut down by the authorities.

3 May

Students at the Sorbonne University met to protest against the closure of Nanterre. A far-right group, Occident, enflamed tempers by threatening to attack the manif (demo).The police scattered the “righties” and then began to remove the “lefties”, about 400 were brutally arrested. Demonstrators gathered, and the first pavés (cobble stones), were thrown at police. The Paris police, supported by the notorious CRS riot police, responded with indiscriminate baton charges and volleys of tear gas, assaulting students, journalists, passers-by, tourists, cinema-goers and even those just sitting at café terraces.

rue-saint-jacques-may-1968

Rue Saint-Jacques, May 1968

 5 May

Radicals occupied the Sorbonne administration building and held a general assembly. The police surrounded and closed down the university.

rue-gay-lussac-may-1968

Rue Gay-Lussac, May 1968

 6 May

Over 20,000 members of the National Students’ Union and the Union of University Teachers marched towards the Sorbonne, still sealed off by the police, who charged, wielding their batons, as the marchers approached. The crowd built barricades and threw pavés, forcing the police to retreat. The police responded with tear gas and hundreds more students were arrested.

boulevard-saint-germain-6-may-1968

Boulevard Saint Germain, 6 May 1968

rue-saint-jacques-6-may-1968

Rue Saint-Jacques, 6 May 1968

7 May

A 50,000 strong march against police brutality turned into a day long battle through the narrow streets and alleys of Paris’ Latin Quarter. When the police fired tear gas, some protestors responded with Molotov cocktails.

police-retaliation

Police retaliation!

10 May

Another huge crowd congregated on the Rive Gauche. When the riot police blocked them from crossing the river, the crowd again threw up barricades.

barricade-on-the-boulevard-saint-germain-near-rue-hautefeuille

Barricade on the Boulevard Saint-Germain near Rue Hautefeuille

11 May

The police attacked the barricades at 02:15 in the morning. The confrontation, which resulted in hundreds of arrests and injuries, lasted until dawn. A large crowd of students tried to “liberate” the Sorbonne, which had been ringed by the CRS. Trees were ripped up, cars overturned and pavés hurled – exposing the sand below, and leading to the best known anarcho-libertarian slogan of 1968: Sous les pavés, la plage (Literally; under the cobbles, the beach, but metaphorically; after the battle, a better life).

sous-les-paves-la-plage

Sous les Pavés la Plage

sous-les-paves-la-plage-2

12 May

The Education Minister started negotiations. The police withdrew from the Latin Quarter. Students seized the sections of Paris which police had sealed off and created an assembly to spread the struggle. Occupations and demonstrations spread throughout France. The Parti Communiste Français (French Communist Party) reluctantly participated with the major union federations – the Confédération Générale du Travail and the Force Ouvrière.

aftermath

Aftermath

13 May

The trade unions, against the advice of their own leaders, called a one-day strike and demonstration. Over a million students and workers marched through Paris. Prime Minister Georges Pompidou personally announced the release of prisoners and the reopening of the Sorbonne.

aftermath-2

Aftermath

14 May

The strikes did not end as the union leaders planned. Eight million workers went on indefinite, wildcat strike. Students occupied the Sorbonne and declared it an autonomous “people’s university”. Around 400 popular action committees were set up in Paris to take up grievances against the government and French society.

15 May

The National Theatre in Paris was seized and made into a permanent assembly for mass debate.

20 May           

The numbers on strike escalated to ten million, roughly two-thirds of the French workforce. 4,000 students marched from the Sorbonne to support Renault strikers, but union officials locked the factory gates and the Parti Communiste Français urged their members to stop the revolt.

24 May

An attempt was made on to burn down the Bourse (the Paris stock exchange). The Prime Minister, Georges Pompidou, began negotiations with the unions. Cohn-Bendit was expelled from France. Army generals readied 20,000 troops to take Paris by force and police occupied TV stations, Post Offices and other communications centres. Parti Communiste Français officials helped coerce strikers into returning to work.

girl-waving-flag-in-crowd-during-general-strike-from-lifes-may-24-1968-coverage-of-the-paris-uprisings

Girl waving flag in crowd during general strike, From LIFE‘s May 24, 1968 coverage of the Paris uprisings

25 May

The Grenelle agreements were signed at the Ministry of Social Affairs. These provided for an increase in the minimum wage and average salaries. The offers were rejected as inadequate by workers and the strike went on.

29 May

De Gaulle left France for Baden-Baden in West Germany for talks with the French military high command.

30 May

500,000 protesters marched through Paris.

31 May

De Gaulle announced by radio (the national television service was on strike) the dissolution of the National Assembly with elections to follow. He ordered workers to return to work, threatening to institute a state of emergency if they did not. A huge counter-demonstration by De Gaulle supporters blocked the Champs Elysées.

5 June

Most workers returned to work or were ousted from their workplaces by the police. The National Student Union called off street demonstrations. The government banned a number of leftist organisations.

6 June

The police retook the Sorbonne. The trades unions accepted a 10% increase in general wages and a 35% increase in the minimum wage, a shorter working week and mandatory employer consultations with workers.

23 June

De Gaulle triumphed in the elections and the crisis in France came to an end.

 

No political group can claim ‘68 – it was a spontaneous mass outburst, not instigated or led by any external power. Its weakness was that it allowed the unions and the Parti Communiste Français to limit and fragment the movement. Ten million workers participated in the largest wildcat strike in history, but they allowed communist union officials to keep control. The occupations of workplaces were used by the unions to keep the workers separated from the wider movement of students.

 

Slogans and graffiti

Sous les pavés, la plage.  (Literally; under the cobbles, the beach, but metaphorically; after the battle, a better life).

Je suis Marxiste, tendance Groucho. I am a Marxist of the Groucho variety.)

Soyez réalistes, demandez l’impossible.  (Be realistic, demand the impossible.)

La barricade ferme la rue mais ouvre la voie. (The barricade blocks the street but opens the way.)

Pas de replâtrage, la structure est pourrie.  ( No replastering, the structure is rotten.)

Le patron a besoin de toi, tu n’as pas besoin de lui  (The boss needs you, you don’t need him.)

Travailleur: Tu as 25 ans mais ton syndicat est de l’autre siècle. (Worker: You are 25, but your union is from the last century.)

Il est interdit d’interdire. (It is forbidden to forbid.)

La poésie est dans la rue. (Poetry is in the street.)

Ne me libère pas, je m’en charge. (Don’t liberate me, I’ll do it myself.)

Si vous pensez pour les autres,  les autres penseront pour vous.  (If you think for others, others will think for you.)

   how-can-i-think-freely-in-the-shadow-of-a-church                                                                    Comment penser librement à l’ombre d’une chapelle?                                                     How can I think freely in the shadow of a church?

The Dead

lordre-regne

The death which featured most in the media was that of Police Commissioner René Lacroix in Lyon, “crushed by a truck in which the accelerator pedal had been stuck”, according to police statements. Yet contrary to reports at the time, the commissioner might not have been struck by the vehicle, but may have died of a heart attack after his arrival at hospital.

Mainstream French media continues to claim that there were no demonstrator fatalities during May, whilst socialist / liberal media point to a small number of fatalities in June:

June 10

Gilles Tautin, a 17 year old high school student, drowned in the Seine at Flins after a brutal beating, trying to escape a CRS charge outside the Renault plant in Meulan.

June 11

Pierre Beylot, shot dead, and Henri Blanchet, killed by a grenade, during a CRS attack on the Peugeot factory in Sochaux.

June 29

Marc Lanvin, an 18 year old communist activist shot dead by assassins hired by the Union des Démocrates pour la République, (UDR), a Gaullist political party. The murder weapon had been provided by the Service d’Action Civique (SAC), a Gaullist militia responsible for covert actions in North Africa.

Surprisingly, both main stream and left wing media ignore the following:

May 24

Philip Mathérion, aged 26, whose body was found at dawn on the barricade in Rue des Ecoles, 75005 Paris. The autopsy report remains secret, but his death has been attributed to either stabbing or shrapnel wounds from a grenade.

the-barricade-on-rue-des-ecoles

The barricade in Rue des Écoles

crs-charging-students-on-rue-des-ecoles

CRS charging students in Rue des Écoles

Of course history is written by the victors but the 1968 uprising in general and the death of Philip Mathérion in particular have been air brushed out of French history in a way that the Paris Commune and the massacre of the last 147 communards has not. There is no memorial to the 1968 uprising anywhere within the Boulevard Périphérique which defines central Paris. The only one that I could find was in the communist controlled outer suburb of Malakoff, and this was specifically dedicated to Marc Lanvin, a Parti Communiste Français member.

memorial-to-marc-lanvin-in-the-suburb-of-malakoff

Memorial to Marc Lanvin in the suburb of Malakoff

It took 40 years for Paris to erect a memorial to the Algerians killed in the 1961 massacre, in only two years it will be the 50th anniversary of the 1968 uprising, surely long enough to wait for a memorial to Philip Mathérion and his comrades?

Conclusions

So apart from six dead and more than a few bruised heads, what did the uprising achieve?

Who actually won?

On the one hand, De Gaulle won his election and was able to cling to power for a little longer. On the other, France joined the permissive society, and the swinging sixties finally started to swing. The workers achieved a huge pay rise, a shorter working week and improved conditions. By joining together to fight De Gaulle and the ancien régime, the students and workers won better lives for themselves. France became something of a workers’ paradise in a way that the Soviet Union never was. Even today, standards of living in France are comparable with Britain and Germany, whilst the quality of life is significantly better. Compare France to its Mediterranean neighbours, Spain and Italy, and its economy is spectacularly miraculous! So everyone was a winner and all the players walked away with prizes? Up to a point yes, but there were serious consequences for Paris, France and the rest of the world:

The main boulevards in the Latin Quarter were tarmacked over rather than re-cobbled, you now have to walk the back streets to find traditional cobbled roads.

The Parti Communiste Français and unions were exposed, to those who didn’t know already, as agents of the establishment, counter-revolution and status quo.

The Sorbonne was broken up and divided into thirteen universities managed by a common rectorate, the Chancellerie des Universités de Paris. Three universities now have the word in their name: Panthéon-Sorbonne University, Sorbonne Nouvelle University and Paris-Sorbonne University.

Worse, was the destruction of Montparnasse on the orders of Georges Pompidou , trying to demonstrate that he was tougher than De Gaulle and wanting to inflict punishment on the left bank for supporting the uprising. The artists’ quarter and beautiful old railway station, where the Nazis surrendered Paris to the Allies and scene of the famous train accident, were bulldozed and replaced by a 209 meter 59 floor brutalist tower symbolising a huge grey tombstone in reference to the adjacent Montparnasse cemetery. It casts its malevolent shadow over the left bank as a warning and deterrence against future unrest.

montparnasse-station-oct-22-1895-engine-120-721-failed-to-stop-went-through-a-window-and-fell-onto-the-street-below

Montparnasse station Oct 22, 1895, engine 120-721 failed to stop, went through a window and fell onto the street below!

tour-montparnasse-a-210-metre-tall-blight-on-the-landscape

Tour Montparnasse – a 210 metre tall blight on the landscape

The CRS continue to police in a heavy handed manner. The following two photos were taken in Boulevard Beaumarchais during a peaceful music parade from Place de la République to Place de la Bastille on 14 September 2014. Some days later the CRS beat the merdre out of Muslim demonstrators outside Voltaire metro station.

p1040934

Quels hommes!

p1040940

Quels poseur!

 

The consequences for the rest of the world were more sinister. There were no successful outcomes to what was almost global unrest anywhere other than France. To find the reasons for this we must examine in detail the mysterious trip to Baden-Baden in West Germany by De Gaulle on 29 May. This was supposed to be to ensure that he had the support of his generals in the event of military intervention becoming necessary, but this doesn’t stand up to scrutiny. If he had required homage from his generals, he would have summoned them to the Palais de l’Élysée where he could have arrested any waiverers, pour l’encouragement des autres. On the other hand, if the generals had been planning a mutiny or coup then turning up in Baden-Baden would have played into their hands, they could have simply arrested him and declared martial law.

But the loyalty of his generals was never in doubt. What was very much in doubt was the continued support of the Parti Communiste Français in the event of military intervention. If the military had intervened and if the Parti Communiste Français had then switched sides, there would have been a very bloody civil war with an unknown outcome.

The only way to ensure continued Parti Communiste Français support was to negotiate with their ultimate leader, Leonid Ilyich Brezhnev, General Secretary of the Central Committee (CC) of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU). As we have seen with Guantanamo Bay, foreign military bases are usefully beyond the reach of civilian state, constitutional and legal protocols. In Baden-Baden, De Gaulle and the French military were free to do as they pleased.

De Gaulle fought against the Bolsheviks in Poland in 1920, but subsequently developed a special relationship with the communists dating back to the Second World War when most of the resistance to the Nazi occupation of mainland France prior to D-Day was carried out by the Parti Communiste Français and directed by the CPSU in Moscow. In all probability, however, it was General Jacques Massu who negotiated continued support from Brezhnev. Brezhnev would not have handed out ex gratia concessions to the west, so in return he would have wanted a free hand in Czechoslovakia. This was not within De Gaulle’s gift to concede, so Massu must have negotiated an agreement with NATO (France left NATO in June 1966), and similarly NATO, i.e. the United States, would have demanded concessions from the Soviets. The United States was just as worried as the Soviet Union about the events in France and certainly didn’t want any of this “European revolutionary nonsense” spilling over the Atlantic into the Americas. The resultant three way deal will have given the United States a free hand to supress youthful unrest in the Americas. The following chronology reads like an outline for a Frederick Forsyth novel, but is factual:

1 July

The United States and Soviet Union signed the Nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty.

15 July

The United States and Soviet Union signed an agreement on cultural, scientific, educational and technological exchange. The first direct air link was opened between the United States and Soviet Union. Newsweek magazine admited that the United States and Soviet Union “have often found themselves undergoing many of the same internal and external stresses and strains in the rapidly changing world of the 1960s.”

16 July

A Parti Communiste Français delegation, led by Waldeck Rochet, met Brezhnev in Moscow.

17 July

The Parti Communiste Français proposed a meeting of all European Communist Parties to deal with the situation in Czechoslovakia.

19 July

Leaders of the Parti Communiste Français (Rochet and Kanapa) met in Prague with Czechoslovakian leaders (Dubček, Černík, Lenárt, and Císař).

22 July

The United States notified the Soviet Union that it would not intervene in Czechoslovakia.

20 August      

Armies from four Warsaw Pact countries – the Soviet Union, Bulgaria, Poland and Hungary – invaded Czechoslovakia, ending the so-called “Prague Spring” experiment of “communism with a human face”. 108 Czech and Slovakian civilians were killed and around 500 wounded. The west did nothing.

9 September

De Gaulle condemned the Soviet intervention in Czechoslovakia but said that he would continue the policy of détente nonetheless.

2 October      

Following months of growing unrest in Mexico, ten days before the start of the Summer Olympics, police, paratroopers and paramilitaries fired on a student demonstration in La Plaza de las Tres Culturas at Tlatelolco, Mexico City, killing up to 300 people in a storm of bullets. The USA had sent military radios, weapons, ammunition and provided riot control training. The Soviets and their allies did nothing.

5 October      

A now declassified CIA memo concluded that recent student unrest in Mexico was sparked by domestic conditions. Cuban and Soviet involvement was limited to moral and some financial support.

8 October      

A now declassified FBI cable emphasized the necessity of concealing the FBI’s role to avoid jeopardizing ongoing FBI operations in Mexico.

 12 October    

The 1968 Mexican Olympic Games commenced as planned, the only country to boycott was North Korea due to an unrelated dispute.

“The goal of the Olympic Movement is to contribute to building a peaceful and better world by educating youth through sport practiced without discrimination of any kind and in the Olympic spirit, which requires mutual understanding with a spirit of friendship, solidarity and fair play.”

Quels hypocrites!

For further information, please see: “L’Accord secret de Baden-Baden” by Henri-Christian Giraud, published April 24, 2008 and available on Amazon.fr, unfortunately I’ve been unable to find an English translation.

be-young-and-shut-up

Be Young and Shut-Up

So the Fifth Republic was saved,  France prospered and the price was paid, not just in blood by the Czechs, Slovaks and Mexicans, but by 23 more years of the iron curtain, cold war,  and Soviet oppression in Eastern Europe. Imagine what could have been achieved if the Parti Communiste Français had supported their Czech and Slovak comrades instead of taking orders from Brezhnev!

return-to-normal

Return to normal…

So who should have the final word on the events of ’68? Perhaps one of the soixante-huitards (sixty-eighters), a pro-market, pro-European, libertarian, German Green Party Euro MP now in his sixties who played a part in the events of ’68;

“I say forget May 1968, it is finished. Society today bears no relationship with that of the 1960s. When we called ourselves anti-authoritarian, we were fighting against a very different society.”

Why do his views matter?

His name is Daniel Cohn-Bendit!

It would be very easy to view the Cohn-Bendit of today through Orwellian eyes, one of the pigs now running the farm, but that would be a mistake. In a simplistic division between angels and demons, Cohn-Bendit is one of the angels. Perhaps he is right, at least from a Franco-German perspective? Cohn-Bendit is not responsible for the failure to export the last French revolution, but he fails to see ’68 from a global perspective.

daniel-cohn-bendit-2016

Daniel Cohn-Bendit 2016

Ultimately, the lack of global success in ’68 resulted from the states under threat being prepared to inflict more violence on their citizens than their citizens were prepared to inflict on their states. So the last word should go to someone who had a much better understanding of the state / citizen relationship, the late Mao Tse-Tung, former Chairman of the Communist Party of China, who said;

“Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun.”

A chilling warning to anyone planning to use the upcoming fiftieth anniversary as an opportunity to complete the unfinished business of ’68!

political-power-grows-out-of-the-barrel-of-a-gun

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s